China · Case commentary
Are Non-Circumvention Clauses Enforceable in China? One Court Said Yes and Cut the Damages
Show the clause wording
During the cooperation, neither party may, for any reason, through its company or any individual, deal privately with customer orders the two parties are already working on. After the cooperation ends, [the factory] may not deal with any customer [the trader] has previously worked with. A party that breaks these terms shall pay the other party RMB 300,000, unconditionally.
That's my translation of two clauses from a 2020 agreement. A trading company and a factory in Zhongshan, Guangdong signed it. The clauses come from a published judgment. Compared with most NNNs I review, it's rough. (An NNN is a non-disclosure, non-use and non-circumvention agreement.) It has no end date and no list of customers. Its damages figure has nothing behind it. A Chinese court enforced it anyway, and the appeal court agreed. Then it awarded a third of the figure.
Has your factory gone around you to your customer? Then read this case closely for three things:
- the argument that the customer made the first move got nowhere;
- the missing end date nearly mattered;
- the damages came down for reasons you can plan around.
It's one basic-level judgment (from the lowest tier of Chinese courts), upheld on appeal. A court in another city could see it differently. Also, the factory never raised the antitrust argument. That argument has since sunk a clause of much the same shape in the Supreme People's Court. I come back to that below.
How the deal came apart
The trading company had customers and no production. The factory had production. The arrangement was simple. The trader won orders and passed them to the factory. It sold the goods on in its own name and kept the difference.
- 20 November 2020. The two sign the agreement with the clauses above.
- 9–29 December 2021. A customer in Dongguan places orders through a WeChat group set up for its orders. The factory's staff are in the group. The factory makes the goods and delivers them to the trader. The trader delivers them to the customer under its own name. The factory bills the trader RMB 76,639.80. The customer later pays the trader RMB 107,608.27.
- 29 December 2021. The trader's last order to the factory.
- 3 January 2022. The customer posts an order in the same WeChat group. This time it is addressed to the factory. From then on, the customer buys from the factory directly. The trader stops sending the factory work.
- March 2023. The trader sues for the RMB 300,000. It also claims RMB 30,968.47 of lost margin.
- 6 June 2023. The Zhongshan No. 2 People's Court awards RMB 100,000 and nothing else.
- 1 September 2023. The Zhongshan Intermediate People's Court dismisses the trader's appeal.
One detail deserves more attention than it got in court. The trader put its customer and its factory in the same group chat. Later, the customer gave the factory a signed statement about what happened next. It had found out that the trader had no production of its own and that the factory was making its goods. So from January 2022, it moved the business to the factory to cut costs and secure supply. That's a commercial problem, and no clause solves it. The clause decides what the breach costs the factory. It can't stop a customer who can see the factory from wanting to buy there.
Was the clause valid?
Yes. But the court added a time limit of its own.
The factory's main attack was that the ban after the cooperation ended had no end date. Read literally, the factory could never deal with any customer the trader had ever served, however many years passed. The factory said this was so unfair that the clause should be void. It added that it had never approached the customer. It also said a contract between it and the trader couldn't bind the customer's own choices.
The court dealt with validity in three steps. First, the trader hadn't imposed the clause as a standard term. The two sides negotiated it, it was clear, and it was what both sides meant. Second, its purpose was to stop the factory from taking the orders the trader brought and then using that opening to trade around the trader. The court called this an expression of the good-faith principle. Third, the ban after the cooperation ended did add to the factory's burden and limit its freedom. But the court looked at why the parties signed and what they were trying to do. It held that the ban was valid "within a reasonable period."
So the court saved the clause by reading in a limit the parties never wrote. That worked for the trader because the breach came within days. If the factory had waited eighteen months, the argument would have been much harder. The court never said where a reasonable period ends. It didn't need to. A clause with no end date leaves that question to whichever judge hears the case.
Did it matter that the customer made the first move?
No. This is the part I'd show a factory that says "they came to us."
The court held that it made no difference who contacted whom first. Dealing with the customer directly was a breach either way. Say the cooperation had in effect ended once the trader stopped placing orders. The factory still owed its duty after the cooperation ended, for a reasonable period. And it had started trading with the trader's customer only days after the trader's last order. The court said that went against good faith.
Two phrases in the clause gave that result: "for any reason" and "through its company or any individual." Many English-language NNNs I see say only that the supplier "shall not solicit" the buyer's customers. To solicit means to approach someone for business. If that's all yours says, the factory's defence is already written for it. It didn't solicit anyone. The customer called. So write the clause about dealing with the customer. And say in plain terms that it doesn't matter who made contact first.
How much was it worth?
RMB 100,000 of the RMB 330,968.47 claimed.
The factory argued that the trader's real profit from the whole cooperation was RMB 13,484.90. It asked the court to cut the damages to 30% of that figure. The trader put its own lost margin at RMB 30,968.47. That was the gap between what the customer paid and what the factory charged, over that one month in December 2021.
The court landed between the two positions, but much closer to the trader's. It set the damages at RMB 100,000. It based this on:
- the trader's earnings;
- the factory's degree of fault;
- fairness;
- the fact that liquidated damages in Chinese law are partly meant to punish. (Liquidated damages are the fixed sum a contract says a party must pay if it breaks the contract.)
It refused the separate claim for lost margin, for two reasons. One month of trading was no basis for working out lost profit. And the RMB 100,000 already compensated the trader. On appeal, the trader argued that it had paid for all the work of finding the customer. It said the factory had taken a long-term customer from it. The appeal court held that the RMB 100,000 wasn't obviously wrong, and left it alone.
Now compare the award with the numbers. It's about three times the one month of margin the trader could prove. It's about seven times the profit figure the factory put forward. That's a meaningful result for a trader whose clause was badly drafted. It's also well short of the figure in the contract, and the evidence explains most of the gap. A long-term customer is worth the orders it would have placed next year and the year after. The trader proved one month.
The rules have become stricter since this case. In December 2023, the Supreme People's Court issued an interpretation on contract law. It covers requests to reduce liquidated damages:
- courts start from the actual loss;
- a figure more than 30% above the loss is generally too high;
- a party in bad-faith breach generally can't get a reduction at all.
The Zhongshan judgments came before that interpretation. I can't tell you whether a court today would say this factory acted in bad faith. But the rule gives you two reasons to keep records. Evidence of the loss sets the base. Evidence of what the factory knew affects whether it can ask for a cut. Here, the factory's own staff sat in the group chat where the customer placed the trader's orders.
What this case doesn't tell you
It's one ordinary judgment from a basic-level court in Guangdong. The intermediate court above it upheld it. Chinese judgments don't bind later courts the way precedent does in common-law systems. A court in another city could weigh the same facts differently.
The factory also didn't argue antitrust (competition law). In December 2024, the Supreme People's Court struck down a clause that stopped a producer from selling to its trader's customers. It found that the two were competitors at the point of sale, and that the clause divided customers between them ((2024) Zui Gao Fa Zhi Min Zhong No. 350, 13 December 2024). I've written about the competition-law risk for middlemen here. A factory's lawyer today would probably run both arguments. The Zhongshan clause covered every customer the trader had ever served, with no end date. That is broad in exactly the ways the antitrust argument attacks. Zhongshan shows a court enforcing this kind of promise when the only objection was fairness. Whether the same clause would survive an antitrust defence is a separate question. On the current authority, I'd expect it to struggle.
Both companies were Chinese, the contract was Chinese and the court was Chinese. For a foreign buyer, none of this helps unless your NNN is written to be enforced in a Chinese court. It has to work against the Chinese company that signed it.
And the clause bound the factory. It never bound the customer. The customer was free to buy wherever it liked. Your claim is against the factory, and it's a claim for money.
The clause, rewritten
Here's what I'd change. I'd keep what worked.
Who is protected. The original: every customer the trader had ever worked with. What I'd write: customers named in a schedule (a list attached to the contract). Or customers identified in orders, project files or a written notice the factory has received. Add a promise that the factory will confirm, on request, whether a given company is covered. A factory can't sensibly be held to a promise about customers it had no way of identifying. A defined list is also far easier to defend against the antitrust argument.
How long. The original: no end date. What I'd write: a fixed period for each protected customer. It counts from your last order involving that customer. Orders the factory takes from that customer itself don't extend it. Then you're no longer relying on a judge to decide what's reasonable.
What counts as a breach. The original: dealing privately, for any reason, through the company or any individual. What I'd write: keep all of that. Extend it to the factory's related companies. Say expressly that it doesn't matter who made contact first. And exclude anything you instructed, such as a delivery or a site visit you asked for.
What it costs. The original: RMB 300,000, flat. What I'd write: a figure with a stated basis. For example, a multiple of the gross margin on that customer's orders over the previous twelve months, with a minimum amount. Then keep the order history, the invoices and the margin records that prove the base. That's what the court will ask for.
One last point concerns how you run the deal. If your business depends on the factory never meeting your customer, don't put them in the same chat group.
Questions from overseas buyers
Does it matter that the customer contacted the factory first?
Not in this case. The court held that it made no difference who contacted whom first. Dealing with the customer directly was a breach either way. The clause helped by covering dealings "for any reason" and "through its company or any individual".
What happens if my non-circumvention clause has no end date?
The Zhongshan court read in a "reasonable period" and never said where it ends. That worked for the trader because the breach came within days. A fixed period for each protected customer, counted from your last order involving that customer, takes the question away from the judge.
Can a Chinese factory attack the clause under competition law?
It can try, and a factory's lawyer today probably would. In December 2024, the Supreme People's Court struck down a clause that stopped a producer from selling to its trader's customers. It found the clause divided customers between competitors. In my view, a clause covering every customer with no end date would struggle against that argument.
Can the clause stop my customer from buying directly from the factory?
No. The clause bound the factory. It never bound the customer, which was free to buy wherever it liked. Your claim is against the factory, and it is a claim for money.
Has your factory already started dealing with your customer? Send a short summary and the company names. Once I've checked that I don't act for the other side, I'll ask for the agreement, the order history with that customer and the chat records. I'll tell you where you stand and what your options are. 48-hour incident support →
Sources and translations
- Zhongshan No. 2 People's Court, a trading company v. a factory, (2023) Yue 2072 Min Chu No. 5709, judgment of 6 June 2023.
- Zhongshan Intermediate People's Court, same parties, (2023) Yue 20 Min Zhong No. 5512, judgment of 1 September 2023 (appeal dismissed).
- Civil Code of the PRC, art. 585 (adjustment of liquidated damages).
- Supreme People's Court, Interpretation on Certain Issues Concerning the Application of the General Provisions of the Contracts Book of the Civil Code (Fa Shi [2023] No. 13 (in Chinese)), issued 4 December 2023, art. 65.
Translations of the clause and the judgments are mine and unofficial. Check the originals before relying on them.
Have a China-side question?
Tell us what you plan to share and with which Chinese company. Say whether anything has already been sent, and which documents you have. The responsible lawyer replies within one calendar day. We will tell you where you stand and what your options are.