China · Practical guide
How to Check a Chinese Supplier's Court and Enforcement Records
A common search result is one line: "Subject to enforcement, 3 cases." Buyers often ask whether that means they should walk away. It depends on what the three cases were, when they were filed, and whether they are still open.
Chinese courts publish a lot about companies that have been sued or have not paid a judgment. Commercial databases collect it in one place. If you read it carefully, it is one of the most useful parts of a supplier check. If you read it quickly, it can scare you off a sound supplier. It can also make you feel safe about a weak one.
The main records
Judgments. Many civil judgments are published online. A supplier's record may show disputes with customers, suppliers, employees or landlords. What matters is the pattern. One old dispute with a landlord says little. Several recent claims by buyers over quality or non-delivery say a lot.
Enforcement cases. A company appears here when a creditor has asked the court to enforce a judgment or award against it. An open enforcement case means someone has a final decision and hasn't been paid yet. A closed one may mean the debt was paid. It may also mean the court found nothing to seize.
Dishonest judgment debtors. This list is more serious. A company goes on it for several reasons. One is when it can pay and refuses. Another is when it blocks enforcement. It is a strong warning sign.
Consumption restrictions. Courts can stop a debtor and its legal representative from certain spending, such as air travel and luxury hotels. If a supplier's legal representative is on this list, it usually means unpaid court debts.
Case filings and hearing notices. These show cases that have started but not yet ended. They are the most up-to-date warning you will find. A judgment may still be months away.
How to read them
In 17 of my 58 checks, the supplier had an enforcement record or was on the dishonest-debtor list.
- Check dates. A cluster of cases in the last year matters more than a few old cases from a decade ago.
- Check the other party. Claims by customers about delivery or quality are directly relevant to you. Labour or lease disputes may reflect cash-flow strain.
- Check the amounts against the company's size. A large company will have some disputes. What matters is whether the debts are large for its size.
- Check whether cases are open or closed. Some enforcement cases close because the debt was paid. Others close because no assets were found. These are very different signals.
- Check related companies and the legal representative. Problems sometimes sit in a sister company or with the owner personally. If the same people run a company that has been blacklisted, ask why.
What these records can't tell you
Arbitration is mostly private. Many business disputes go to arbitration, and arbitration awards are not published. A clean court record doesn't rule out arbitrations.
Publication is incomplete. Not every judgment is published, and databases lag behind the courts.
A clean record is no guarantee. A new company, or one that has so far avoided disputes, can still fail to deliver. Solvency and capacity need separate checks.
Names can collide. Always search by the unified social credit code (the company's official registration number). Database sites sometimes attach cases to the wrong company when names are similar.
What to do with a bad record
A poor record doesn't always mean you should walk away. It may mean you should change the terms:
- smaller deposits;
- payment after inspection;
- a letter of credit;
- a guarantee from the parent company;
- a shorter first order.
If the risk is serious, the record gives you a clear reason to ask for these terms without accusing anyone.
Questions from overseas buyers
Does "subject to enforcement" mean I should walk away from a Chinese supplier?
Not necessarily. It depends on what the cases were, when they were filed and whether they are still open. An open case means a creditor has a final decision and hasn't been paid yet. A closed case may mean the debt was paid, or that the court found nothing to seize.
What is China's dishonest judgment debtor list?
This list is more serious than an ordinary enforcement case. A company goes on it for several reasons, such as refusing to pay when it can, or blocking enforcement. It is a strong warning sign.
Should I search a Chinese supplier by its name or its registration number?
Use the unified social credit code, the company's official registration number. Database sites sometimes attach cases to the wrong company when names are similar.
What should I do if a supplier's court record looks bad?
A poor record doesn't always mean you should walk away. It may mean you should change the terms: smaller deposits, payment after inspection, a letter of credit, a parent-company guarantee or a shorter first order. If the risk is serious, the record gives you a clear reason to ask for these terms without accusing anyone.
Part of my guide to checking a Chinese supplier.
Are you about to pay a Chinese supplier you haven't worked with before? Send me its name and a short outline of the order. Ask about a supplier check →
Have a China-side question?
Give us the supplier's name as it appears on the quotation or invoice. List the documents you have, such as the contract or order and the supplier's last message. The responsible lawyer replies within one calendar day. We will tell you where you stand and what your options are.