You paid a Chinese supplier. The shipment or refund you were promised did not arrive. The excuses keep changing. Messages are being deleted. Or the person who took your order has suddenly stopped answering.
Save the record while you still can, before you send more messages.
Proving that money left your account is the easy part. The case depends on four things. Which company made the promise? Which company got the money? Who spoke for them? And what links the three? Once you can show those links, a lawyer can tell you quickly whether a letter, an asset freeze or a lawsuit fits your case.
Chinese courts look closely at how evidence was kept. The five published judgments below show what that means. Most were disputes between two Chinese parties. The same evidence rules apply when a foreign buyer sues.
1. The signed contract, purchase order and every set of terms
Keep the document that both sides signed. Then keep going. Save the purchase order and the pro forma invoice (the invoice a seller issues before you pay). Also save the quotation, the sales confirmation and any standard terms the two sides swapped before payment.
Check three things:
- Do the Chinese and English versions name the same company?
- Is the dispute clause in both versions?
- Did later emails or messages change delivery dates, specifications or refund promises?
Don't edit the originals. Keep clean copies and working copies apart.
2. The complete payment trail
Save the bank transfer confirmation, the SWIFT message and the payment instruction. Note the beneficiary name, account number, bank name, currency, amount and date. If the supplier asked you to pay into a new account, save the message that gave the new details.
Write down who asked for the payment. Write down how that person explained the link between the account holder and the factory. You may have paid a Hong Kong company, a private person or an unrelated trading company. If so, that can change a lot about how you get the money back.
3. The supplier’s exact Chinese legal identity
An English trading name is not enough. If you have them, save the Chinese company name and the unified social credit code (the company's official registration number). Also save the registered address and the legal representative (the person registered to act for the company). You can find these on the business licence, the company chop (the official company seal), the contract, the invoice and the public company register.
Put each name in a simple table. Note where you found it. The problem often starts where the names don't match.
Then link each chat account to that identity. A WeChat or WhatsApp display name proves little. Note the phone number on the contact card. Check it against the contract, the invoice and the company record.
4. Every version of the invoice and quotation
Save each quotation, commercial invoice and pro forma invoice. Keep the ones that were later replaced too. File names and file data can help show when the terms changed. If an invoice has a company chop or bank account on it, keep a high-resolution copy.
5. The full communication history
Export full email threads. For WeChat, WhatsApp and other chat apps, save the contact profile, the account ID, the dates and the whole conversation around the key lines. Screenshots of the best lines alone are not enough.
The order of events usually matters more than one admission. It may show the first promise, an agreed extension, an excuse, a promise to refund and then silence. Back up screenshots somewhere other than your phone. Where you can, save important voice messages in their original format.
China's Supreme People's Court (SPC) has issued rules on civil evidence. A party relying on electronic data must produce the original (SPC Provisions on Evidence in Civil Proceedings, art. 15). A copy that can't be checked against the original can't prove a fact on its own (art. 90). So keep the chats on the phone or account where they happened. Don't delete the app or reset the phone. If you change phones, move the full history first.
6. Proof that the person speaking had a role
Keep email signatures, business cards, staff pages, trade-show records and messages that show the person’s job title or authority. If the person used a company email address, write it down. If they used a personal account, save whatever shows the company presented them as its sales rep, manager or owner.
7. Specifications, samples and quality requirements
The dispute may be about faulty goods, or goods swapped for something else. If so, save the approved sample, drawings, bill of materials, colour references, testing standard, packaging requirements and acceptance criteria. Note which version was approved and when.
Saying the goods were “bad” is weak. A clear comparison is much stronger. Show what was agreed, what was delivered and how you recorded the difference.
8. Inspection, production and logistics records
Keep inspection reports, photos, videos, production updates, packing lists, booking confirmations, bills of lading, airway bills and messages with freight forwarders. Where you can, keep the original files. Copies forwarded through chat are often compressed.
If the goods never shipped, save each production or shipping date the supplier promised. Save its excuse for missing each one.
9. Refund promises and proposed settlement terms
Save every promise to refund, replace goods, give a credit or repay in instalments. Note the amount, the date and any conditions. If the supplier sent a draft settlement or repayment plan, keep every version, even if nobody signed it.
Don't call a proposal a final agreement unless the record shows it was one. A lawyer needs to tell three things apart: an admission, a position taken in negotiation, and a binding settlement.
10. Your notices and the supplier’s responses
Save the notices you already sent, proof that they were delivered, and every reply. Make a short timeline: payment, promised delivery, missed deadline, notice, refund promise and the last real reply.
The timeline should point to the documents. It can't stand in for them. For each event, note the date, the people involved, the amount and the file that proves it.
11. Public-facing material that may disappear
If they are relevant, save the supplier’s website pages, marketplace profile, product listings, staff descriptions and listed addresses. Note the page URL and the date you saved it. A bookmark alone is not enough. Pages and profiles can change once a dispute starts.
12. A clean loss calculation
Keep the main payment separate from freight, inspection fees, replacement costs, lost profits and other losses you claim. Keep the proof for each number. A clear calculation shows which amounts are easy to prove. It also shows which losses may be disputed or cost more to chase than they are worth.
Documents from outside China
Many of your records will be in English. Many were also created outside China. Two rules matter here.
Anything in another language needs a Chinese translation
Every document in a foreign language must come with a Chinese translation (art. 17). A long email chain takes time and money to translate. Start with the messages that matter most.
Not every foreign document needs an apostille
Only two kinds of evidence made outside China need formal certification (art. 16). The first is official documents. The second is evidence about personal status, such as marriage or family ties. For official documents, certification means notarisation in that country, or the steps set by a treaty. Evidence about personal status also needs certification by the Chinese embassy or consulate, unless a treaty sets other steps. China joined the Apostille Convention in 2023. For countries in that convention, the treaty step is usually an apostille, a single certificate that confirms a public document is genuine.
For a foreign buyer, this usually means bank records, emails and reports from private inspection firms need no apostille. Company registration documents are official documents, so they usually do. My guide to instructing a Chinese lawyer from abroad covers that step. Which step applies also depends on the law of the country where the document was made and on any treaty that country has with China. A lawyer should confirm this for your own documents before you pay for certification.
What not to do while preserving evidence
- Don't delete messages that hurt your case. Don't present part of a conversation as the whole thing.
- Don't edit screenshots, rename original files or overwrite source documents.
- Don't threaten criminal action, public exposure or unrelated harm to force payment.
- Don't send originals to the supplier or anyone else without keeping safe copies.
- Don't wait for the supplier’s next promise before you back up what you have now.
The practical test
Once your file is in order, four questions become easy to answer. Who took on the duty? Who got the money? What breach do the documents prove? Does the supplier have assets you can reach?
Evidence does not guarantee you get your money back. It does make the first review faster. It also stops you spending money on a demand or a lawsuit that your records can't support.
Questions from overseas buyers
Are screenshots of WeChat or WhatsApp messages enough evidence?
Often not. In a Huidong case, a seller offered only printouts of WeChat chats. It did not produce the original chats when the court asked. The court dismissed the whole claim. Keep the chats on the phone or account where they happened, and save the full conversation around the key lines.
The supplier's WeChat name doesn't match the company. Does that matter?
It can decide the case. In a Zhongshan case, the buyer appeared under a different name in the seller's WeChat, and the claim was dismissed. In a Hefei case, the phone number on the WeChat contact card matched a business registration form, and the seller won. Note the phone number on the contact card. Check it against the contract, the invoice and the company record.
I paid a different company from the one in the contract. Does that matter?
It can change a lot about how you get the money back. Write down who asked for the payment. Write down how that person explained the link between the account holder and the factory. If the supplier sent new bank details, save that message too.
Do my English documents need a translation or an apostille?
Every document in a foreign language must come with a Chinese translation. Only official documents and evidence about personal status need formal certification when made outside China. Bank records, emails and reports from private inspection firms usually need no apostille. Company registration documents usually do. Which step applies also depends on the law of the country where the document was made and on its treaties with China. A lawyer should confirm it for your documents.
This article is general information on PRC law. It isn't advice on any particular matter. The right way to save evidence and to recover money depends on the documents, the parties and the court or arbitration body in each matter.
Sources and translations
- Huidong County People's Court, Guangdong, (2021) Yue 1323 Min Chu No. 7566, judgment of 8 February 2022. This is a first-instance judgment. No appeal appears in the published records.
- Zhongshan No. 1 People's Court, (2020) Yue 2071 Min Chu No. 1176, judgment of 30 June 2020. This is a first-instance judgment. No appeal appears in the published records.
- Baohe District People's Court, Hefei, (2020) Wan 0111 Min Chu No. 14540, judgment of 16 December 2020; upheld by Hefei Intermediate People's Court, (2021) Wan 01 Min Zhong No. 1849, judgment of 3 March 2021.
- Chaoyang District People's Court, Beijing, (2020) Jing 0105 Min Chu No. 29457, judgment of 17 August 2020. This is a first-instance judgment. No appeal appears in the published records.
- Tianjin No. 1 Intermediate People's Court, (2020) Jin 01 Min Zhong No. 2886, judgment of 14 July 2020, on appeal from (2019) Jin 0104 Min Chu No. 8109.
- SPC Provisions on Evidence in Civil Proceedings (Fa Shi [2019] No. 19 (in Chinese), in force 1 May 2020), arts. 15, 16, 17 and 90.
Translations are mine and unofficial. Check the originals before relying on them.
Official texts cited in this article.