Home / Articles / Deposit or Prepayment? Getting a Refund From a Chinese Supplier That Never Delivered

China · Case commentary

Deposit or Prepayment? Getting a Refund From a Chinese Supplier That Never Delivered

Many overseas buyers believe Chinese law protects their "deposit". If the Chinese supplier fails to deliver, they expect to get back twice the amount. Sometimes they do, but often they don't. In the case below, the contract was missing one sentence.

I acted for an overseas buyer in exactly this situation. The court ordered the supplier to return the start-up payment. It also ordered the supplier to pay the compensation set out in the contract. It refused the claim for double repayment. I help overseas buyers recover payments from Chinese suppliers that never delivered.

What happened

My client was an industrial services business. It ordered a batch of specialised instrument modules through the Chinese manufacturer's own online ordering portal. On the portal, the manufacturer confirmed several things:

Both sides then signed electronically.

My client made a start-up payment. The rest was due as each batch passed remote acceptance.

The delivery date passed. The manufacturer changed its control chip design several times. It said a component was no longer made. My client agreed to a short extension and to swap some batches. The manufacturer then uploaded demonstration material. It didn't match the serial information in the contract. The agreed temperature-range check was never finished. The two sides kept discussing fixes in the portal's support tickets. In the end, the manufacturer admitted it could not meet the confirmed specifications any time soon.

My client sent a termination notice through the portal. It asked for the start-up payment back, plus the fixed compensation in the contract.

What the manufacturer argued

The manufacturer said it had bought special components. But it showed no purchase, assembly or test records that matched the order line by line.

How the court dealt with it

The portal created a contract. The portal records set out the goods, price, delivery, payment and refund rules. Both sides used verified company accounts to confirm and sign. My client paid against the order. That was enough.

The support tickets counted. Every ticket was linked to the same order. The manufacturer's technical replies matched its version records, remote demonstrations and confirmations from its managers. The court treated the tickets as the manufacturer's own statements.

The termination was valid. After several extensions, the manufacturer still had not delivered modules that met the contract. It had not finished the agreed verification. The contract ended when the termination notice reached the manufacturer. Later, the two sides talked about turning part of the money into a repair service package. That never became a new order, so it changed nothing.

The start-up payment was part of the price. The contract called it the first instalment of the price. It said nothing about securing performance, losing the payment or double repayment. The contract also had its own remedy for non-delivery. The supplier had to return the money paid and add fixed compensation. The court held that the parties had chosen that remedy. It refused double repayment.

No interest on top. The fixed compensation covered the normal cost of being without the money. So the court did not add interest.

The rule behind it

Chinese law allows a real deposit (dingjin) that works as security. Say the party who received it fails to perform, and as a result the purpose of the contract can't be achieved. Then it must pay back double (Civil Code art. 587). The deposit can't be more than 20% of the contract price. Any amount above that is not a deposit at all (art. 586).

What you call the money doesn't decide it. A party may pay something called a guarantee, security, earnest money or a "deposit" in the loose sense. The parties have to agree that the money is a dingjin, in the contract or in later written messages. If they never did, a court will not apply the double-return rule (SPC Interpretation on the General Part of Contracts in the Civil Code, art. 67). In English documents the problem is worse. People use "deposit" for every kind of upfront payment.

Side by side, under Chinese law:

Deposit (dingjin, 定金)Prepayment (预付款)
What it isSecurity for performance. The parties must agree the money is a dingjin, in the contract or in later written messages (SPC Interpretation art. 67)Part of the price, paid early
LimitNot more than 20% of the contract price. Any amount above that isn't a deposit (Civil Code art. 586)No 20% limit
The supplier fails, so the purpose of the contract can't be achievedIt pays back double (art. 587)It returns the money and pays your proven loss or the agreed compensation (art. 566). There is no double repayment
The buyer fails, so the purpose of the contract can't be achievedYou lose the deposit (art. 587)You don't automatically lose the money, unless the contract says so. The supplier can claim its loss from your breach (art. 566)
The contract also fixes compensation for breachThe innocent party chooses the deposit or the compensation, and can claim any loss above the deposit (art. 588)The contract's remedy applies, as in the case above

Watch the characters in the Chinese text. 定金 is a deposit. 订金 sounds the same, but unless the parties agree it is a deposit, it doesn't carry double repayment (SPC Interpretation art. 67). If your messages keep calling a prepayment security for performance, a court may treat it as a deposit.

If you want a real deposit

Show the clause wording

Deposit. The Buyer shall pay [amount, not more than 20% of the Contract Price] as a deposit (dingjin) securing the Supplier's performance, within the meaning of Articles 586 and 587 of the PRC Civil Code. If the Supplier fails to deliver the Goods, or delivers Goods that do not conform, so that the purpose of this Contract cannot be achieved, the Supplier shall pay the Buyer double the deposit. On delivery and acceptance, the deposit shall be applied toward the price.

First, decide whether you want this. A deposit works both ways. If you are the one who walks away, you lose it.

Keep the record the court relied on

Questions from overseas buyers

Will I get double my deposit back if a Chinese supplier doesn't deliver?

Only if the parties agreed, in the contract or in later written messages, that the money is a real deposit (dingjin). What you call the money doesn't decide it. A deposit can't be more than 20% of the contract price (Civil Code art. 586). Double return applies when the supplier's failure means the purpose of the contract can't be achieved (art. 587).

Is an order confirmed on a supplier's online portal a binding contract?

It can be. In this case, the portal records set out the goods, price, delivery, payment and refund rules. Both sides confirmed and signed with verified company accounts. The buyer then paid against the order, and the court held that was enough.

Do messages from a Chinese supplier's technicians bind the company?

They can. Here the manufacturer said its support tickets were just technicians talking. Every ticket was linked to the same order, and the replies matched its version records, remote demonstrations and managers' confirmations. So the court treated the tickets as the manufacturer's own statements.

What if the supplier offers to turn my payment into a different service?

Agree it as a new signed order, or say no in writing. In this case, the two sides talked about turning part of the money into a repair service package. It never became a new order, so it changed nothing.

Sources

Official texts cited in this article.


Part of my guide to supplier disputes in China.

Have you paid a Chinese supplier upfront, and the goods haven't come? Send a short summary and the company names. Documents follow after the conflict check. Discuss your supplier dispute →


This article is based on matters I handled. Names, products, places, dates, amounts and other identifying details have been removed or changed. Some facts have been combined. It describes how one court dealt with one set of facts. It doesn't predict the result in any other case.

Have a China-side question?

Tell us what the supplier did or failed to do, and the Chinese company's name. List the documents you have, such as the contract or order, payment records and the supplier's last message. The responsible lawyer replies within one calendar day. We will tell you where you stand and what your options are.

More about you and the Chinese company (optional)

Please do not send confidential documents, passwords, bank details or sensitive personal information in your first enquiry. See our privacy and confidentiality notice.