China · Practical guide
Can a Gulf Judgment or Award Be Enforced Against a Chinese Supplier?
The question usually comes after the decision is already made. "We have a judgment from our court in Dubai against the Chinese factory. How do we collect?" By then, the answer depends on two choices made months earlier, often without much thought. What kind of decision do you hold? And where does the supplier keep its money?
This note sets out the routes for a buyer in the Gulf. It is general information. The right route for a particular contract depends on its wording and on the supplier's assets.
Start with the assets
A Chinese manufacturer's bank accounts, receivables, equipment and property are almost always in mainland China. A decision from any court or tribunal outside China only turns into money once a Chinese intermediate people's court agrees to recognise and enforce it. So you need to know which foreign decisions Chinese courts will enforce, and how. For buyers in the Gulf, I act on the China side and pursue the supplier where its assets are.
The supplier may have assets outside China. Examples are a Hong Kong trading company that receives payments, or goods held in a Gulf free zone. If so, you may be able to act against them locally, and a lawyer there can advise. Check that before anything else.
Route 1: an arbitration award
China and all six Gulf Cooperation Council states are parties to the New York Convention on foreign arbitral awards. So a Chinese court will enforce an award made in the UAE, Saudi Arabia, Qatar, Kuwait, Bahrain or Oman under the Convention. It can refuse only on the Convention's limited grounds. These include:
- there was no valid arbitration agreement;
- a party was not given proper notice or a fair chance to present its case;
- the tribunal went beyond what was put to it;
- the procedure was irregular;
- enforcement would conflict with Chinese public policy.
The application goes to the intermediate people's court where the supplier is based or where its property is (Civil Procedure Law (in Chinese) art. 304). In practice, awards fail in China for ordinary reasons. The award names the wrong Chinese company. The supplier was never properly notified. Or the arbitration clause was written in a way Chinese law treats as unclear. My separate note on a US award that failed in China because of a wrong company name shows how this happens.
Route 2: a Gulf court judgment
Court judgments are harder. A Chinese court recognises a foreign judgment only under a treaty or on the basis of reciprocity (Civil Procedure Law arts. 298 and 299). Reciprocity means each country's courts are willing to enforce the other's judgments.
Treaties. China has judicial assistance treaties with the United Arab Emirates and with Kuwait. Both provide for recognition and enforcement of each other's court judgments in civil and commercial matters (art. 17 of each). Each lists grounds for refusal (art. 21 of each). These include a judgment that is not final or enforceable, and a court without jurisdiction. They also include a claim contrary to the law or public order of the state asked to enforce. A default judgment given without proper summons is another ground. The Kuwait treaty covers only judgments given after it came into force. It also confirms that arbitral awards are enforced under the New York Convention (art. 28). A China-Saudi Arabia agreement also covers court judgments (art. 19). It was signed in 2022, ratified by China in 2025, and is now in force. China has no such treaty with Qatar, Bahrain or Oman, so reciprocity applies there.
Reciprocity. For other states, a Chinese court asks a question. Would the courts of the country that gave the judgment recognise a Chinese judgment in similar circumstances? Since 2022, the Supreme People's Court has told lower courts how to find reciprocity. They may find it if the other country's law would allow a Chinese judgment to be recognised. This holds even if no Chinese judgment has yet been tested there (2021 Conference Minutes on Foreign-Related Commercial and Maritime Trials, art. 44).
Grounds for refusal. Even with a treaty or reciprocity, a Chinese court will refuse recognition in these cases (Civil Procedure Law art. 300):
- under Chinese law, the foreign court had no jurisdiction;
- the supplier was not properly summoned or given a fair chance to be heard;
- the judgment was obtained by fraud;
- a Chinese court has already ruled on the same dispute;
- recognition would breach basic principles of Chinese law or public interests.
Notice is the weak point for many Gulf judgments against Chinese companies. Court papers for a company in China must be served under the Hague Service Convention or the relevant treaty. Papers sent by courier or email may not count. Nor may service by publication in the Gulf.
Route 3: sue in China
If you sue the supplier directly in a Chinese court, you skip the recognition step. A Chinese judgment is enforced by the same court system that holds the supplier's assets. The court can also freeze accounts at the start. The downside is that you litigate in Chinese, under Chinese procedure, often in the supplier's home city. For many disputes about goods, prepayments or tooling, this is the quickest route to money. That assumes your contract lets you bring the case there.
What to put in your contract now
- Pick one route and write it clearly. Use an arbitration clause naming one institution and one seat (the city where the arbitration is legally based). Or use a clause giving jurisdiction to a named Chinese court. Avoid "arbitration or court" clauses. Chinese courts may treat them as invalid.
- Name the right Chinese entity. Put its full registered Chinese name and its unified social credit code in the contract.
- Agree on service. Give an address and an email in China for notices and for service of court papers. State this agreement expressly.
- Think about interim relief. You may need to freeze the supplier's accounts before an award is made. If so, the seat matters.
Questions from overseas buyers
Can a court judgment from Qatar, Bahrain or Oman be enforced in China?
China has no treaty with these three states that covers court judgments, so reciprocity applies. A Chinese court asks whether that country's courts would recognise a Chinese judgment in similar circumstances. Since 2022, the Supreme People's Court has told lower courts they may find reciprocity if the other country's law would allow it. This holds even if no Chinese judgment has been tested there yet.
Why would a Chinese court refuse to enforce a Gulf arbitration award?
The New York Convention allows refusal only on limited grounds. Examples are no valid arbitration agreement, or a tribunal that went beyond what was put to it. In practice, awards fail in China for ordinary reasons. The award names the wrong Chinese company, the supplier was never properly notified, or the arbitration clause is unclear under Chinese law.
Is sending court papers to a Chinese supplier by email or courier enough?
It may not be. Court papers for a company in China must be served under the Hague Service Convention or the relevant treaty. Courier, email or publication in the Gulf may not count. A Chinese court will refuse to recognise a judgment if the supplier was not properly summoned (Civil Procedure Law art. 300).
Is it quicker to sue the Chinese supplier in a Chinese court?
Often, yes, if your contract lets you bring the case there. For many disputes about goods, prepayments or tooling, it is the quickest route to money. You skip the recognition step, and the court can freeze the supplier's accounts at the start. The downside is that you litigate in Chinese, under Chinese procedure, often in the supplier's home city.
Part of my guide to China legal work for Gulf buyers.
Do you buy from China for a business in the Gulf? Send a short summary and the company names. Once I've checked that I don't act for the other side, I'll ask for your contract. I will tell you where the pressure points are. Discuss a supplier dispute from the Gulf →
Sources and translations
- Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (New York, 1958).
- Civil Procedure Law of the PRC (2023 amendment), arts. 298, 299, 300 and 304.
- Agreement between China and the UAE on Judicial Assistance in Civil and Commercial Matters (signed 21 April 2004), arts. 17 and 21; Agreement between China and Kuwait on Judicial Assistance in Civil and Commercial Matters (signed 18 June 2007), arts. 17, 21 and 28; Agreement between China and Saudi Arabia on Judicial Assistance and Cooperation in Civil and Commercial Matters (signed 7 December 2022; ratified by the NPC Standing Committee on 30 April 2025; reported in force by the Ministry of Justice, April 2026), arts. 19 and 22.
- Supreme People's Court, Minutes of the National Courts' Symposium on Foreign-Related Commercial and Maritime Trials (Fa [Min Si] Ming Chuan (2021) No. 60), arts. 44 and 46.
Translations are mine and unofficial. Check the originals before relying on them.
Official texts cited in this article.
- New York Convention on the Recognition and Enforcement of Foreign Arbitral Awards (1958) uncitral.un.org
- Civil Procedure Law of the PRC (2023 amendment) court.gov.cn · in Chinese
Have a China-side question?
Tell us what the supplier did or failed to do, and the Chinese company's name. List the documents you have, such as the contract or order, payment records and the supplier's last message. The responsible lawyer replies within one calendar day. We will tell you where you stand and what your options are.