Home / Services

Adrian Liu · China-side legal work

Chinese Supplier Won't Return Your Molds or Tooling?

Before anyone talks about getting them back, sort out who owns them, who holds them and what the full contract record says.

Short answer

  • If a Chinese supplier won't return your molds, work out who owns them, who holds them and what the contract record says before you try to get them back from China.
  • I assess these disputes for buyers whose tooling a Chinese manufacturer is holding, starting at USD 1,950.
  • The assessment usually takes 3–5 business days once I have the agreed materials.
  • Come before any demand is sent, because a demand sent before you settle on the goal tends to harden the supplier's position.

Has the supplier also broken your NNN agreement (non-disclosure, non-use, non-circumvention)? See 48-hour incident support.

Want a quick first look on your own? Try the free self-check for molds a Chinese factory won't return. It has eleven questions, and your answers stay in your browser.

What does a tooling recovery assessment cost?

Tooling / mold recovery assessment from USD 1,950 for a standard defined scope. That means one factory or other main company on the other side, and one related tooling/equipment set. The assessment reviews the agreed ownership, payment, possession and evidence records. It includes a registry check and proposes China-side recovery options. A demand, negotiation, physical collection, preservation application or proceedings are scoped separately. Narrower or very different matters may be quoted separately. Typical assessment turnaround is 3–5 business days after I have the agreed materials and payment is made as agreed.

I have handled 17 mold matters, including demand letters and work outside court. Each involved 5 to 22 molds. The largest involved about USD 100,000. They took between six months and a year and a half. All 17 are closed, by judgment, mediation or private settlement. Past results don't predict the outcome of another matter.

Which four questions decide a tooling dispute?

What exactly is being held?

Identify the tooling, molds or equipment from the records you have. Use descriptions, drawings, photos, inventories and any reference numbers or markings. Keep the original records.

What supports your claim to own it?

Review the contract, development arrangements, quotations, invoices, payment evidence and correspondence. Be clear where the record is complete and where you are making an assumption.

Who holds it and controls it?

Keep the company you signed with apart from the factory or anyone else holding the tooling. If a different company is involved, write down the explanation you were given and who gave it.

Why won’t they return it?

Keep the supplier’s exact words. Note any dispute about unpaid amounts, and the agreed terms for handover or ending the contract. A review has to deal with the supplier’s side as well as your demand to get the tooling back.

What happens first, and what should you send?

First comes the conflict check, to make sure I don’t act for the other side. After that, we agree which documents you send. They may include the manufacturing or development contract, the tooling terms and the payment record. They may also include records that identify the tooling, messages about ownership and access, and the supplier’s refusal or its conditions. Add a short timeline. Also say what result your business needs: access, transfer, replacement or another defined outcome.

What can't the assessment promise?

The assessment is not a recovery order. It doesn’t guarantee access, return or payment. It tells you whether you face an evidence problem, a negotiation question or a matter that may need further legal proceedings. Technical valuation, site access and work outside mainland China need their own scope where relevant.

Can a Chinese supplier hold your molds even though you paid for them?

Sometimes it can. PRC law treats ownership and the right to hold back property as two separate questions. Almost every tooling dispute involves a supplier that accepts the buyer paid for the molds but still won’t hand them over. That isn’t necessarily a contradiction.

Article 783 of the Civil Code usually decides the second question. Say the customer has not paid the contractor’s fee or the cost of materials. Then the contractor has a lien over the finished work, or may refuse to deliver it, unless the parties have agreed otherwise. A lien is a right to keep someone’s property until they pay. Two things follow. First, a supplier that holds back tooling over an unpaid invoice may be using a right the law gives it. Second, the parties can agree to exclude that right. That is why the tooling clause in a manufacturing or development agreement is worth writing before the tooling is made.

A well-drafted tooling clause states clearly who owns the molds. It also:

  • records that the supplier holds them as bailee for the buyer, meaning it keeps them on the buyer’s behalf;
  • requires each mold to be identified and marked;
  • covers access and inspection, and sets the conditions for handover or transfer to another factory;
  • deals with maintenance and expected life;
  • either excludes the article 783 lien or says exactly which sums the lien can secure.

What if your molds are at a company you never signed with?

During a dispute, buyers often find that the tooling is at a company they never signed with. Article 772 of the Civil Code deals with this. Unless the parties agree otherwise, the contractor must do the main work with its own equipment, technology and labour. If it hands the main work to a third party, it stays responsible to the customer for that party’s work. If it did so without the customer’s consent, the customer may terminate the contract.

That gives you rights under the contract against the company you signed with. It doesn’t give you a direct claim against the company holding the tooling. And a third party that has the tooling may say it is owed fees of its own. So you usually need to find out which company holds the tooling, and on what basis, before any demand is sent.

These examples are based on matters I have handled. Names, products, places, dates, amounts and other identifying details have been removed or changed. They show the kind of work involved. They don't promise any result.

Acting for a buyer

The factory couldn't return the molds because a subcontractor held them.

A brand that had paid for its molds ended a manufacturing relationship and asked for them back. The factory accepted that the molds were the brand's, but they were at a subcontractor the brand hadn't known about, and the subcontractor wouldn't release them until the factory settled its own bill. The brand's records described the molds by project name in some places and by internal number in others. I matched the documents to the physical items, got the factory to take on the settlement with its subcontractor, and agreed a written handover: which molds and parts, when, who would count them, who would move them, and how gaps would be recorded. A missing part was supplied before sign-off. The molds went to the new factory without a lawsuit.

Acting for a buyer

The company that quoted wasn't the factory that would hold the molds.

A brand was about to pay for tooling. The quotation came from a trading company, which had also signed the brand's NNN agreement. The molds would be made and kept at a factory in the same group, which is legally a separate company. In my outline of the development and tooling agreement, both companies sign and are jointly liable, and the factory is also bound by the NNN. The molds belong to the brand from its first tooling payment, together with every insert, tool and fixture used to make and plate the part, and the drawings. The factory holds them for the brand. It may not keep them back, even in a payment dispute, and must hand everything over, with the process settings, on written request.

The clause that helps here says the molds are yours from the day you pay and that the factory may not hold them back over any amount it claims. See What Should the Mold Clause Say in a Chinese Factory Contract?

How do you prove which molds are yours?

To get tooling back, the court or the supplier has to know which items are yours. Tooling is often unmarked. The contract often describes it loosely. It may look exactly like other molds in the same workshop. If the drawings, specifications and payment records can’t be matched to specific items, the ownership argument stalls before anyone looks at the merits.

These help:

  • a schedule listing each mold with a reference number, cavity count (how many parts it makes per cycle) and the part it makes;
  • photos taken when you accepted the molds;
  • markings that survive handling;
  • payment records that refer to the schedule item by item. A single lump sum is hard to match to particular molds.

Which court tools can protect your molds early?

Evidence preservation. If evidence may be lost or hard to get later, a party may ask the court to preserve it. In urgent cases, an interested party may apply before starting a lawsuit or arbitration (Civil Procedure Law (in Chinese), 2023 revision, art. 84). This matters when the proof you need is inside premises you can’t enter. That proof may be the molds themselves, production records or the parts coming off them.

Asset preservation. This is a court order that freezes or seizes the other side’s assets. On an urgent application made before a lawsuit, the court must rule within 48 hours. If it grants the application, it must carry it out at once. In practice a freeze usually takes 10 to 15 days. The applicant provides security (usually a deposit, a guarantee or a preservation insurance policy) and must start a lawsuit or arbitration within 30 days (art. 104). If your main aim is pressure, and getting the molds back matters less, this is often the more useful of the two.

Whether either tool is available and sensible depends on the facts and on what you are trying to achieve. Getting a set of molds back and being paid for them are different goals. They take different routes.

What outcome should you aim for before sending anything?

The realistic outcomes are access while you move production, physical transfer to another factory, payment for replacement, or an agreed wind-down. Each needs different steps. A demand letter sent before you settle on the goal tends to harden the supplier’s position. It moves you no closer to any of them. Sometimes the supplier also has technical information it shouldn’t use elsewhere. Then the tooling question and the confidentiality position are usually handled together.

Why does the type of contract matter?

Tooling terms are usually written into a manufacturing or purchase relationship. The terms that decide a tooling dispute are often in whichever contract governs the work. Suppose the supplier makes molds to your drawings and specifications. Then the arrangement has the features of a contract for work under Chapter 17 of the Civil Code. That is a contract to make something to the customer’s order, and the law treats it differently from a simple sale. The rules on the contractor’s duties, subcontracting and the lien over finished work apply to it.

This has real effects. Because of it, article 783 decides whether the supplier may hold the molds against unpaid sums. Between businesses, a supplier may also hold property over an unrelated debt (art. 448), unless the contract rules this out (art. 449). And article 772 gives you a right to terminate if the main work went to a third party you didn’t approve. If the contract says nothing on these points, the default rules in the law apply. Those defaults were not written with a foreign buyer in mind.

What should you agree before the tooling is made?

Almost every tooling dispute goes back to a document that said nothing about one of the points below. Each is cheap to agree in advance and expensive to argue about later.

  1. Ownership, stated clearly. Who owns each mold, from when, and whether ownership passes on payment, on acceptance or on completion.
  2. A schedule that identifies the items. Reference number, cavity count, the part it makes, and the sums paid for each. Without this, an ownership argument has nothing to attach to.
  3. Possession terms. Say that the supplier holds the molds for you and may use them only for your orders. Say also that it may not move them, pledge them as security or make them available to anyone else.
  4. The lien position. Whether the article 783 right to hold back the molds is excluded. If it isn’t, exactly which sums it can secure. Giving the supplier an unlimited legal lien over your tooling because of a disputed invoice is a poor bargain.
  5. Handover mechanics. The notice period, where the molds go, who pays for removal and transport, and what condition they must be in. If you have a right to get tooling back but no process for doing it, you will have to sue to use that right.
  6. Maintenance and life. Who maintains the molds and who pays. The expected shot life (how many cycles a mold should last). What happens when a mold is worn or damaged.
  7. Subcontracting consent. Whether the molds may go to another workshop at all. If so, on what conditions, and what promise the holder must give.

If the same relationship also involves drawings and technical information, put these terms next to the confidentiality obligations. Kept in separate documents, they are rarely read together. A China NNN agreement covers the information. The tooling terms cover the physical asset. The manufacturing agreement is usually where both come together for production.

Questions from overseas buyers

I paid for the tooling. Doesn’t that settle who owns it?

Payment is an important part of the record. The assessment also needs the development and contract terms, what the payment covered and how the tooling is identified. A payment statement alone doesn’t settle every possible dispute.

Should I send a demand right away?

First be clear on the recipient, the supporting records and your next step. Tell me about any risk to the tooling or any deadline coming up. Then the response can take them into account.

Can you look at related company and IP records?

The agreed assessment can include relevant company and IP records. A separate filing, a specialist patent opinion, a full investigation or recovery action isn’t automatically part of the initial fee.

Can you help prevent the same problem on the next project?

Manufacturing and development agreements can cover ownership, custody, permitted use, access, handover and what happens when the relationship ends. A new contract is a separate piece of work from the current dispute.

Related services and reading

This page gives general information about the service and how to prepare. It isn’t advice on any particular transaction. The documents, parties, legal questions and scope are assessed for each new matter.

Discuss the tooling being withheld

English or Chinese.

Is a supplier holding your molds or tooling? Tell me what is being held, who holds it, the reason they give and any urgent deadline. After the conflict check, send the contract, the payment records for the tooling and the supplier’s messages refusing to return it. I’ll tell you where you stand and what your options are.

My first reply is free. It sets out the information I need and the work I would propose. It isn't a full review of your documents. Send an outline without confidential details first. Sensitive documents come after the conflict check, once we agree how to share them.

Start with a short summary and the parties’ names for a conflict check. Please wait for us to confirm how to share documents before sending sensitive files. Sending an enquiry does not make us your lawyers.

Deadline or contact preferences (optional)

Please do not include confidential documents, detailed personal records or sensitive business information. Sending an enquiry does not make us your lawyers. We take no action until you hire us. Don't rely on this form to meet a deadline. Privacy notice

Adrian receives your enquiry and coordinates with the responsible lawyer. English or Chinese.