Home / Services / 48-hour supplier breach response

Adrian Liu · China supplier breach response

Your Chinese supplier broke the NNN. The next 48 hours decide what you can still prove.

Lead lawyer: Adrian Liu · PRC lawyer, licensed since 2021 · Xiamen · 74 supplier-dispute lawsuits
Licence 13502202110350464 · How to verify · Reviewed

Short answer

  • If your Chinese supplier has broken the NNN, capture the evidence before any lawyer’s letter goes out; a letter sent first mostly tells the factory what to delete.
  • I act for overseas buyers whose factory is keeping their tooling, selling their design on 1688 or Alibaba, passing their work to a subcontractor or going around them to their client.
  • 48-hour incident support starts at USD 3,500 and covers an evidence plan, a registry check and the first Chinese lawyer’s letter, sent within 48 hours.
  • Don’t argue on WeChat or withhold money you owe, and hold off on any platform complaint; the first step is a 60-minute call for USD 350.

Most of what decides how this ends happens before any lawyer's letter goes out. Is the evidence captured while it still exists? Do you avoid the few moves that hand the factory a defence? A letter sent before that mostly tells the other side what to delete.

First step: a 60-minute call, USD 350, to go through the facts and your options. If you go ahead: 48-hour incident support from USD 3,500. It covers the evidence plan, a registry check and the first Chinese lawyer's letter, out within 48 hours. The 48 hours start once the scope is confirmed in writing, the fee has arrived and we have your documents.

What should you do today, before you call anyone?

  1. Stop arguing on WeChat. Angry messages and threats end up in the other side's evidence file. Say nothing you wouldn't want a judge to read.
  2. Don't hold back money you owe to put pressure on the factory. Say a payment to the factory is due and you withhold it. The factory then has a simple debt claim. It also has a reason to keep your tooling. That's usually a better position for it than the ownership argument it would otherwise have to win.
  3. Delete nothing. Keep every chat, email and file as it is, including the ones that look bad for you.
  4. Don't file a platform complaint or contact the factory's customers yourself yet. The wording and the order of steps matter. A rejected complaint is hard to take back.
  5. Screenshot now, with the URL, date and time visible. For a court, a notarised capture, where a notary records the page, carries more weight than a screenshot. I'll arrange that. Your own screenshots are a backup in case the page disappears first.
  6. Collect the paper. Start with the signed contract, including the sealed signature page. Add the NNN, your non-disclosure, non-use and non-circumvention agreement. Add the purchase orders, proforma invoices (the invoices a seller issues before you pay) and payment records. Add your tooling list with photos, and the chat history with the factory.
  7. Find out exactly which company you're dealing with. You need its full registered Chinese name. You also need its unified social credit code, the company's official registration number. The "factory" you've been talking to is often a trading company. A letter to the wrong company does nothing.

These examples are based on matters I have handled. Names, products, places, dates, amounts and other identifying details have been removed or changed. They show the kind of work involved. They don't promise any result.

Acting for a buyer

Paid a fake bank account after a hacked supplier email

A buyer paid a large sum into a new account given in an email that looked like it came from the supplier. The same day, the supplier said it had not changed its account and had not been paid. Within hours, I helped the buyer file a recall request and fraud report through its bank's formal channels, and confirm the facts with the supplier through contact details already verified. I had the buyer keep the original emails with full headers, the payment proof and the complete message history. Over the first two days, we prepared the police report and kept adding the receiving account details, a payment timeline and the supplier's written statement. Part of what was left in the receiving account was frozen, but most of the money had already moved on. Some of it was later returned through the official process, and the client decided not to pursue the rest. The first two days went on containment and evidence. The matter itself took months.

Hacked Email, Fake Bank Details: Do I Still Owe My Chinese Supplier? →

What should you start on day one if this may go to court?

A lawyer's letter needs only a simple authorisation signed by your company. That's why it can go out within 48 hours. Suing, arbitrating or asking a court to freeze assets is different. The court will want your company's power of attorney and proof that the company exists. Both must be notarised where you are and then apostilled. If your country hasn't joined the Apostille Convention, they are legalised through a Chinese consulate instead. The Convention has applied to China since 7 November 2023. Which step applies also depends on the law of the country where the document was made and on its treaties with China. A lawyer should confirm it for your documents. The power of attorney can skip these steps if your signatory signs it before a Chinese judge, in person or by video. The company documents still take weeks. If there's any chance of going to court, start it the same day as the letter.

Acting for a buyer

The supplier stopped replying after the prepayment

After a buyer paid a prepayment, the supplier stopped replying, and the buyer heard the warehouse was being cleared and the office was moving out. On day one, I checked the company's registration, litigation and enforcement records, saved the contract, payment records and full chat history, and checked where the reports of the move had come from. On day two, once the buyer had provided its company and authorisation documents, I prepared a statement of urgency and the known bank account details, arranged security, and applied to the court for asset preservation before filing suit. The court froze funds, though not enough to cover the whole claim. We sued within the period the law requires after a freeze, and court mediation produced a refund in instalments. The buyer recovered most of the prepayment. When the supplier defaulted again, the client decided not to pursue the rest.

What do the first 48 hours cover?

The factory won't return your tooling

I gather the ownership records and your proof of payment. I check the reason the factory gives for keeping the tooling. Then I send a Chinese lawyer's letter demanding its return. Whether the factory can lawfully keep it depends mainly on two things: who owns it, and whether money is due. Where money is owed, pay the undisputed part and demand the tooling in the same letter. That is often cheaper than arguing. If the tooling may be moved or destroyed, I'll tell you whether to apply for a court preservation order (see the questions below).

This one has its own page, with a defined assessment: Tooling & equipment recovery →

Your design is on 1688 or Alibaba

The listing is captured and a test purchase is made in front of a notary. That ties the seller to the physical product. Then I compare the seller with your factory. A platform notice goes in only where a Chinese right supports it. A Chinese design patent or trademark works best. A copyright claim is possible, but harder to prove. The seller may answer with a counter-notice. If so, you have 15 days from when it reaches you to file a complaint or a lawsuit. If you don't, the platform restores the listing (E-Commerce Law art. 43). That's why the power of attorney starts on day one.

The factory passed your work to a subcontractor

A letter requires the factory to name every subcontractor and what each one received. It must stop any further transfer and get your drawings back. A processing contractor is a factory that makes goods to your order. Chinese law expects it to do the main work itself. If it hands that work to a third party without your consent, it stays answerable to you, and you may terminate. Auxiliary (supporting) work can be passed on. The factory stays responsible for the result (Civil Code arts. 772–773). You then decide whether to approve the subcontractor or pull the work.

Where drawings went out, preserve the delivery records, what was sent and who received it, then cut off further access. The letter also asks how the files will be recovered. If a claim follows, it turns on two separate questions: which term was breached, and what loss you can prove.

In a published case, a factory gave 20 of a buyer's 108 part drawings to two outside workshops without consent and had them make some of the buyer's parts. When the two sides ended their contracts through mediation, the buyer kept its right to sue over the leak. The court found the factory in breach but cut the liquidated damages claimed from RMB 600,000 to RMB 50,000. It weighed how long the contract had run, how many drawings went out, where the parts went, and the fact that no other products made from the drawings had been found. Shanghai Jiading District People's Court, (2013) Jia Min Er (Shang) Chu Zi No. 1812, 24 March 2014. This is a first-instance judgment. No appeal appears in the published records. For a buyer, how much the court awarded depended on what the evidence showed about the harm, such as how many drawings went out, where the parts went and whether anything else was made from them. Gather that before you agree how the relationship ends, and keep your right to sue in the exit terms, as this buyer did.

If the subcontractor is holding your goods over unpaid fees, don't pay on a promise. Before you pay, have whoever controls the goods confirm in writing what it will deliver and when, how the payment comes off your original price, and who refunds if the goods don't arrive. Where you can, pay and take delivery at the same step.

The factory is dealing with your client

Before anything is sent, I check your non-circumvention clause for competition-law risk. That clause stops the factory going around you to your customers. A clause that covers every customer you've ever had can be attacked as an agreement to divide up customers. Where confidentiality and non-use are the stronger ground, the first letter relies on them.

In the first 48 hours, preserve the customer-protection terms, the record that the customer was yours, past orders and proof of the direct deal. Separate ordinary technical contact with your customer from orders taken in breach. The letter then names the customers and orders involved and asks the factory to stop and keep its records. Meanwhile I work out the profit lost on those orders.

In a published case, a Zhongshan court enforced a factory's promise not to deal with a trader's customer. It cut the agreed RMB 300,000 to RMB 100,000. Zhongshan No. 2 People's Court, (2023) Yue 2072 Min Chu No. 5709, 6 June 2023; appeal dismissed by Zhongshan Intermediate People's Court, (2023) Yue 20 Min Zhong No. 5512, 1 September 2023. Name the customers you want protected, and expect a court to weigh the agreed sum against what you earned from them.

How a Chinese court handled one of these cases →

Acting for a buyer

Goods held by a logistics company over the supplier's unpaid fees

A buyer had paid in full, but just before shipment was told the goods could not be released. The logistics company said the supplier owed it fees. On day one, I collected the purchase contract, payment proof, warehouse receipt and transport instructions. I checked who had handed the goods over, who was to pay the freight, and what the logistics company relied on to hold them, and wrote to both the supplier and the logistics company for an itemised list of the fees and documents. On day two, I brought the three parties together and separated the fees for this shipment from the supplier's older unpaid bills. They signed a written arrangement: the supplier paid the confirmed fees, the goods were released in time for a rescheduled sailing, and the supplier repaid the small sum the buyer had advanced to keep the booking.

When is it better not to pursue the factory?

  • You owe the factory money that is due. Pay the part you don't dispute first. Fighting over tooling while you're behind on payments puts you on the wrong side of the argument.
  • The seller on 1688 isn't your factory, and you hold no Chinese design patent or trademark. A platform complaint will probably be rejected. Your NNN binds only the company that signed it. Once a design is public, it is usually too late to register it as a Chinese design patent (Patent Law art. 23). There is a six-month grace period if someone disclosed it without your consent (art. 24). Check whether that fits your facts before you rely on it.
  • The tooling is old. If remaking it costs less than recovering it, remake it. I'll ask you early for a quote to replace it. That figure is also the basis of any later claim for your loss.
  • The subcontracted work was auxiliary. If no drawings left the site and quality hasn't suffered, ask for disclosure. Also ask the subcontractor for a signed undertaking, meaning a written promise. A fight costs more than it protects.
  • The factory met your client on its own. If it met them at a trade fair and used nothing you gave it, the claim is weak.
  • You signed with a trading company. Then the factory owes you nothing under the contract. The first job is to work out which company does.

What does it cost, and what's included?

60-minute call, USD 350. Before the call, you send the contract and a short account of what happened. By the end of the call you'll know where you stand, what your options are and what the first step would cost. You also get a short written list of next steps.

48-hour incident support, from USD 3,500. If you go ahead with the 48-hour response within 30 days after the call, the USD 350 call fee is credited in full against the incident-support fee. It includes:

The 48 hours start once the scope is confirmed in writing, the fee has arrived and I have the contract, the links or photographs and the other company's details. Notary appointments and Chinese public holidays can move the notarised steps. Notary, test-purchase, platform and court fees are paid at cost. Preservation applications, negotiation and proceedings are scoped separately. No outcome is promised. A letter can't force a factory to do anything. It is often only the first step in building a record.

Questions buyers ask in the first hour

Can you get the listing taken down within 48 hours?

I can't promise that. Within 48 hours, the evidence is captured. Where a Chinese right supports it, the platform notice is ready or filed. How fast the platform acts is up to the platform.

Do I need to come to China?

No. The letter needs only a signed authorisation from your company. Court proceedings need the power of attorney described above. You can have it notarised and apostilled where you are, or sign it before a Chinese judge by video. Which step applies also depends on the law of the country where the document was made and on its treaties with China. A lawyer should confirm it for your documents.

Can a court stop the factory moving my tooling?

It can. Before you sue, you can ask a Chinese court for a preservation order. This is possible if waiting would cause harm that can't be undone. You have to provide security, such as a deposit, a guarantee or a preservation insurance policy. The court must rule within 48 hours of accepting the application. In practice a freeze usually takes 10 to 15 days. You must then sue or start arbitration within 30 days, or the order is lifted (Civil Procedure Law (in Chinese) art. 104). The security is the part you need to decide on. So I'll set out the options and their cost first.

The factory still has my goods in production. Should I send the letter anyway?

Usually not yet. Get the goods out first. Or send a softer notice that reserves your rights, meaning it keeps your claims open. The first letter's timing matters more than its tone.

Will the letter make the factory delete evidence?

It might. That's why the evidence is captured before the letter goes out.

Send a short summary and the other company's name.

English or Chinese.

Once I've checked that I don't act for the other side, I'll ask for what you have. That means the contract, the links or photos and the company's name. I'll tell you where you stand and what your options are.

Start with a short summary and the parties’ names for a conflict check. Please wait for us to confirm how to share documents before sending sensitive files. Sending an enquiry does not make us your lawyers.

Deadline or contact preferences (optional)

Please do not include confidential documents, detailed personal records or sensitive business information. Sending an enquiry does not make us your lawyers. We take no action until you hire us. Don't rely on this form to meet a deadline. Privacy notice

Adrian receives your enquiry and coordinates with the responsible lawyer. English or Chinese.