China · Practical guide
Can I Hold Back the Balance Until a Chinese Supplier Fixes Defects?
The goods have arrived, and some don't match the order. The balance is due, and the supplier wants it now. You want the defects fixed first.
Chinese law lets you hold back money in this situation. It also sets limits. Hold back too much, or skip the written notice, and you can end up in breach yourself. Breach means failing to do what the contract requires. Whether to hold back money is an early decision when I handle a supplier dispute for a buyer.
When you can hold back the balance
The rule is in art. 526 of the Civil Code. It applies when one side must perform first. If the party who goes first performs in a way that doesn't match the contract, the other party may refuse the "corresponding" performance.
If the balance falls due after delivery or after inspection, the supplier goes first. Defective goods then let you refuse the matching part of the balance.
If the balance falls due before shipment, you go first. The rule then protects the supplier, which may wait for your money before it ships.
If the contract sets no order, payment and delivery are due at the same time. The same limit applies (art. 525).
How much you can hold back
The key word is "corresponding". The rule gives no right to freeze the whole balance over a small problem.
The law sets no formula. For a price reduction, a court can compare two values at the time of delivery. One is the market value of goods that meet the contract. The other is the value of the goods you received (SPC Interpretation on Sale Contract Disputes, art. 17). In my view, that difference, or the cost of fixing the defect, is the easiest figure to defend.
In a published case, a buyer of plastic router housings held back payment of about USD 377,000. The routers' end customer in the US had found cracks, and the supplier had sent replacement parts. The defective parts were worth about USD 81,000 at their unit prices. The Wujiang District People's Court in Suzhou held that the buyer could refuse payment until the defect was fixed. But it could hold back only an amount roughly equal to the compensation the defect could lead to. Its defence did not cover the excess. It also ended five days after the last replacement parts arrived without problems, and from then on the buyer owed interest for paying late ((2018) Su 0509 Min Chu No. 3653). Keep the amount close to the cost of the defect, and pay it once the defect is fixed.
Give notice first
Holding back money only works if the defect still counts in law. That depends on notice.
You must inspect the goods within the agreed inspection period, or promptly if none is agreed (Civil Code art. 620). Then tell the supplier about any problem with quantity or quality:
- If the contract sets an inspection period, notify within it.
- If not, notify within a reasonable time after you found the problem, or should have found it. The outer limit is two years from receipt, unless a quality guarantee period applies.
Miss the deadline and the goods are treated as meeting the contract (art. 621). A court will then reject the quality claim (SPC Interpretation on Sale Contract Disputes, art. 14). The deadlines don't bind you if the supplier knew, or should have known, the goods were wrong.
Send the notice in writing. Name the order, the defect, the number of units and your evidence, such as photos or an inspection report. Save the record as you go.
Timing matters too. Raise the defect in writing as soon as you find it.
What to ask the supplier to do
Your notice should also say what you want. If the contract sets the remedy, follow it. If not, you can choose a reasonable remedy, given the goods and the size of the loss. The options are repair, making the goods again, replacement, return, or a lower price (Civil Code art. 582).
Say how much you are holding back and how you worked it out. Say you will pay it once the supplier fixes the defect, or keep it as a price reduction. Pay the rest on time.
When holding back backfires
The balance is money you owe. A party that fails to perform a contract duty, or performs it badly, is liable for breach (Civil Code art. 577). Money you hold back without a basis is unpaid price. That happens if you hold back more than the defect justifies, or if you miss the notice deadline. The supplier can then sue for it (art. 579). Even without a late-payment clause, a court can add the supplier's loss from late payment (SPC Interpretation on Sale Contract Disputes, art. 18).
In a published case from Guangdong, a construction company bought steel tower parts. Twenty parts, a small share of the order, arrived a month late, and the buyer held back the balance of about RMB 100,000. The Jiangmen Intermediate People's Court applied the same rule, then in art. 67 of the old Contract Law. It held that a buyer relying on this right must tell the supplier it is refusing to pay, and why. There was no evidence that this buyer had. The amount refused must also match the problem, and the right ends once the supplier puts things right. Here the supplier had performed its main obligation, and twenty late parts could not justify holding back the balance. The buyer had to pay the balance, a late-payment penalty and the supplier's lawyer's fees under the contract ((2021) Yue 07 Min Zhong No. 1745). If you hold back, tell the supplier in writing, and keep the amount in line with the problem.
If the CISG applies
The CISG is the UN convention on international sales. It applies when buyer and seller are based in different countries that have both joined it, unless the contract excludes it (CISG arts. 1(1)(a) and 6). You must examine the goods as soon as is practicable. Give notice within a reasonable time, and at the latest two years after handover, unless a contract guarantee period says otherwise (arts. 38 and 39). You need not pay before you have had a chance to examine the goods, unless the agreed payment terms rule that out (art. 58(3)). In my view, paying against a copy of the bill of lading (the shipping document) before arrival is such a term.
Build it into the contract
Make the balance payable only after the goods pass an inspection you control. The sample contract check shows one way to word it. A check before shipment catches some defects. For the rest, keep back a set part of the price, called a retention, until you accept the goods. Before you sign, run the free contract check, or see how I approach manufacturing agreements.
Questions from overseas buyers
How much of the balance can I hold back for defects?
The part that matches the defect. Civil Code art. 526 lets you refuse the "corresponding" performance. A sensible figure is the cost of fixing the defect, or the value it takes off the goods. Pay it once the supplier fixes the defect.
Do I have to tell the supplier that I am holding back payment?
Yes. In a published case, an appeal court in Guangdong set a condition. A buyer relying on this right must tell the supplier it is refusing to pay, and why. Do it in writing. Say how much you are holding back and how you worked it out, and pay the rest on time.
What happens if I don't report the defects in time?
The goods are treated as meeting the contract (Civil Code art. 621). Then nothing justifies holding back money, and the supplier can sue for the full balance. If the contract sets an inspection period, notify within it. If not, notify within a reasonable time, and within two years of receipt unless a quality guarantee period applies.
My contract says the balance is due before shipment. Can I still hold it back?
Usually not on this ground. If you must pay before shipment, you go first. Art. 526 then lets the supplier wait for your money before it ships. Fix it in the contract. Tie the balance to an inspection you control, and keep a retention until you accept the goods.
Have defective goods arrived while the balance is still unpaid? Send a short summary and the supplier's Chinese company name. Once I've checked that I don't act for the other side, I'll ask for the contract or order, the payment record and its last message. Photos of the defects help too. I'll tell you where you stand and what your options are. Describe your situation →
Part of my guide to supplier disputes in China.
Sources and translations
- Civil Code of the PRC, arts. 525, 526, 577, 579, 582, 620 and 621.
- Contract Law of the PRC (1999, repealed 1 January 2021), art. 67.
- Supreme People's Court, Interpretation on Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trial of Sale Contract Disputes (2012, amended 2020), arts. 14, 17 and 18.
- Wujiang District People's Court, Suzhou, (2018) Su 0509 Min Chu No. 3653, judgment of 25 September 2018. This is a first-instance judgment. No appeal appears in the published records.
- Jiangmen Intermediate People's Court, Guangdong, (2021) Yue 07 Min Zhong No. 1745, judgment of 15 June 2021, upholding Taishan People's Court, (2020) Yue 0781 Min Chu No. 3227.
- United Nations Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (1980), arts. 1(1)(a), 6, 38, 39 and 58(3).
The CISG is cited from the official UN English text. Summaries of it, and translations of the Chinese texts, are mine and unofficial. Check the originals before relying on them.
Official texts cited in this article.
- Civil Code of the PRC (2020) npc.gov.cn
- UN Convention on Contracts for the International Sale of Goods (CISG, 1980) uncitral.un.org
This article is general information on PRC law. It isn't advice on any particular matter.
Have a China-side question?
Tell us what the supplier did or failed to do, and the Chinese company's name. List the documents you have, such as the contract or order, payment records and the supplier's last message. The responsible lawyer replies within one calendar day. We will tell you where you stand and what your options are.