Home / Articles / Factory overproduction

China · Case commentary

Chinese Factory Making More Than You Ordered? What Courts Award for OEM Overproduction

If a factory keeps making your branded goods without an order, a Chinese court will hold it liable. The court will also order it to stop. In the three cases below, the brand owner won every time. The amounts were RMB 10,000, RMB 15,000 and RMB 30,000.

In each case, the amount depended on two things. The first was what the brand owner could prove. The second was what it had let happen during the relationship. None of the three cases involved a foreign buyer. They are useful because overseas brands run into the same facts with OEM suppliers, especially when a relationship ends.

Case What the factory did What decided the case Award
Luohe, Henan, 2019 Used the brand owner's company name outside the orders A fixed sum per breach, written into the contract RMB 10,000 plus an order to stop
Xiaoshan, Hangzhou, 2019 Made 210 cases of branded drinks after the OEM term expired Trademark infringement; leftover packaging was no excuse RMB 15,000
Foshan, Guangdong, 2019 (appeal) Sold branded egg rolls dated a year after the relationship ended The factory couldn't prove the goods had been ordered RMB 30,000

The fixed-sum clause: Luohe

A Shanghai food company used a factory in Luohe to make its products. Their contract covered two kinds of conduct: making goods or packaging outside the brand's orders, and using the brand's company name. For either one, the factory would pay RMB 10,000 in liquidated damages "regardless of quantity." Liquidated damages are a sum the parties fix in the contract in advance.

The brand found out about the breach in an unusual way. A court in Shaoyang, Hunan, sent it a summons in a dispute it knew nothing about. That is how it learned the factory had been using its company name. The Luohe court's reasoning is two sentences long. The factory broke the contract, so it pays the agreed sum and stops.

The lesson is about how that clause was built. The brand didn't have to prove how many units were made, what they sold for or what it lost. The clause named the conduct and fixed the price. A modest per-breach figure is the kind of clause a court applies without much argument. The weakness is that RMB 10,000 was also the most the brand could get under it. The overproduction clause I draft for manufacturing agreements also makes the factory pay for each unit found.

The leftover packaging: Xiaoshan

A Shaoxing company owned a drinks brand. It had a Taizhou factory make the products under an OEM agreement. The agreement ran from March 2016 to 30 March 2017. It said the factory couldn't sell the branded goods to anyone else. After the relationship ended, the factory couldn't make or sell anything with the brand on it, in any form. If it did, the brand could claim double the factory's sales.

Two weeks after the term ended, the factory made 210 cases of branded coconut drink. It sold 200 to a trading company at RMB 28 a case and gave the rest away. The brand owner reported it to the local market regulator. The regulator inspected the factory, found the packaging in its warehouse and fined it RMB 23,000.

In the civil case, the factory raised three defences. All three failed.

The award was RMB 15,000. The court weighed four things:

The court also rejected part of the claim. The brand had bought some branded drinks from a retailer. Their production dates fell inside the OEM term, so they were genuine stock. The brand couldn't show they came from the factory's unauthorised run.

For an overseas brand, two things in this case matter more than the amount. First, the trademark route was open only because the brand held a registered Chinese trademark. Second, the regulator's inspection gathered the evidence. A private buyer usually can't do that.

The loose ordering: Foshan

A Foshan food company had another local factory make its egg rolls until January 2017. A year later, egg rolls in the brand's packaging turned up. Their production date was 8 January 2018. The factory said they were stock the brand had ordered and never collected. The first-instance court (the trial court) accepted that. The Foshan Intermediate People's Court reversed it on appeal in November 2019.

The appeal court started with the burden of proof, which is the question of who has to prove a point. The production date fell after the relationship ended. The parties had also settled their accounts, and the brand paid the last balance in August 2017. So if the factory said the brand had ordered those goods, the factory had to prove it. Its stock list didn't match the products the regulator had found. The court treated the goods as made without permission, and the factory was liable.

Then the court explained why the damages were only RMB 30,000. This is the part to read closely. The two companies had never fixed production quantities. The factory produced, and the brand collected when it needed stock. Orders were often given by phone. The brand admitted it sometimes accepted more goods than it had asked for. It also left its printed packaging at the factory until mid-January 2018. The court held that the brand was partly at fault. Given the long OEM relationship, it found the factory's fault relatively light. It also noted the factory had made no real profit from the sale.

The brand won because the dates and the settled accounts put the burden on the factory. It got RMB 30,000 because its own way of ordering had made overproduction normal.

What the three cases add up to

Taken together, the cases point to four things. They decide both liability and the amount.

  1. Written orders with fixed quantities. If every order is on paper, anything outside it is unauthorised. If quantities float, the factory can say you took extra before. The court may listen.
  2. Packaging, labels and printing plates. Two of the three cases depended on branded packaging left at the factory. That packaging is the raw material for overproduction. Leaving it there after the relationship ends weakens your position.
  3. A registered Chinese trademark. It gives you an infringement claim as well as the contract claim, and you can choose that route. It also lets you go to the market regulator. Without one, you usually have only the contract.
  4. A clause that prices the conduct. A formula like "double the factory's sales" sounds strong. But you can't prove the factory's sales. A fixed sum per breach is easier to apply. So is a sum per unit found, with a minimum.

What I'd put in a manufacturing agreement

Questions from overseas buyers

Is using up leftover packaging a defence for the factory?

Usually not. It failed in the Xiaoshan case. The factory had printed the packaging during the OEM term. The court held that using it up after the licence ended was still trademark infringement. It was not a lawful way to clear stock.

Who has to prove the extra goods were ordered?

In the Foshan case, the factory did. The goods were dated after the relationship ended, and the parties had settled their accounts. So the factory had to prove the brand ordered them, and it couldn't. The brand's loose ordering by phone still cut the award to RMB 30,000.

What damages clause works against factory overproduction?

A fixed sum for each breach is easier for a court to apply. So is an amount per unit found, with a minimum. A formula like "double the factory's sales" sounds strong, but you usually can't prove the factory's sales. Keep the price and margin records that support your figure.

Do I need a registered Chinese trademark to act against the factory?

You can sue on the contract without one. A registered Chinese trademark adds an infringement claim, and you can choose that route. It also lets you go to the market regulator. In the Xiaoshan case, the regulator's inspection gathered the evidence, which a private buyer usually can't do.


Part of my guide to China manufacturing agreements.

For the trademark side, see China trademarks for overseas brands.

If you think a factory is still making your product, send me the agreement, your last orders and whatever you've found on sale. I'll tell you which route is open to you and what the evidence needs to show. 48-hour incident support →


Sources and translations
  • Luohe Shaoling District People's Court, (2019) Yu 1104 Min Chu No. 365, judgment of 13 February 2019. This is a first-instance judgment. No appeal appears in the published records.
  • Hangzhou Xiaoshan District People's Court, (2019) Zhe 0109 Min Chu No. 1838, judgment of 29 July 2019. This is a first-instance judgment. No appeal appears in the published records.
  • Foshan Intermediate People's Court, (2019) Yue 06 Min Zhong No. 9826, judgment of 25 November 2019 (reversing (2018) Yue 0604 Min Chu No. 27284).
  • Trademark Law of the PRC (2019 amendment), arts. 57 and 63 (arts. 72 and 77 of the revised law in force from 1 January 2027), as applied in the Xiaoshan and Foshan judgments.

Translations are mine and unofficial. Check the originals before relying on them.

Official texts cited in this article.

Have a China-side question?

Tell us the product and the Chinese factory. Say whether you have a draft, a signed contract or orders already running, and which documents you have. The responsible lawyer replies within one calendar day. We will tell you where you stand and what your options are.

More about you and the Chinese company (optional)

Please do not send confidential documents, passwords, bank details or sensitive personal information in your first enquiry. See our privacy and confidentiality notice.