China · Case commentary
Who Owns the Mold When the Chinese Factory Designed the Product?
A brand came to me with what looked like one problem. It turned out to be three.
For several years, the brand bought a product from a Chinese factory through a middleman. It paid for the molds in full. It was promised the only right to sell the product in North America. Then the factory started selling an almost identical version to other customers.
The brand's first question was "who owns this product?" You can't answer that in one go. You have to split it into three:
- Who owns the design and the drawings?
- Who owns the physical molds?
- Does the factory still owe the brand exclusivity?
Each question had a different answer. What the brand could do depended on keeping them separate.
Question 1: the design
The factory created the product. The first idea, the drawings and the CAD files all came from the factory. The brand never asked for real changes to this model. So the brand had no good basis to claim it owned the design, the drawings or the mounting structure.
This is common. Many overseas brands pick a product from a factory's own range and pay the factory to make it. The brand gets the product. It doesn't get the design unless the contract says so.
Question 2: the molds
The molds themselves are a separate asset. Here, the proforma invoice (the invoice a seller issues before you pay) listed the mold cost as its own line. The brand paid it in full. Only then did the factory start making the molds. In my view, if nothing in writing says otherwise, molds made to order and fully paid for by the customer belong to the customer.
The molds stayed at the factory so it could make the product. That's normal. It doesn't make them the factory's molds. The factory only holds them to do the production work.
There was one catch. The proforma invoice named a related company as the buyer. The company that runs the brand today wasn't on it. So on paper, the related company owned the molds. Before the current company could ask for the molds in its own name, it needed a written transfer or authorisation from the related company. If a factory is holding molds you paid for, I assess who owns them and how to recover them.
Can the factory keep the molds anyway?
Factories often say they'll keep the molds until every bill is paid. Chinese law does let a creditor keep property it lawfully holds when a debt is unpaid. This is called a right of retention. It is narrower than factories suggest:
- Usually, the property and the debt must come from the same legal relationship. Between businesses, this link isn't required, as long as the debt arose in the ordinary course of their business (Civil Code art. 448; SPC Interpretation on the Guarantee System, art. 62).
- A creditor can keep a third party's property it lawfully holds if the debt comes from the same legal relationship. Without that link, a business can't keep a third party's property for an unrelated debt. If the owner asks for it back, the court should order its return (SPC Interpretation on the Guarantee System under the Civil Code, art. 62). This matters when you buy through a middleman. Say the middleman owes the factory money for something other than your molds. Then the factory has a weak claim to keep your molds. If the unpaid amount is for the molds themselves, the argument is different.
- Nothing can be kept if the law or the parties' contract says it can't be (Civil Code art. 449). So if your mold clause says the factory has no right to keep the molds, most of this argument never starts.
Question 3: the exclusivity
The factory made only small changes. It added a decorative trim to one part. It swapped one plastic part for a brass one.
Two things followed.
- If the factory used the brand's molds to make the new version, even after changing them, it used the brand's property without permission.
- If it made new molds from the same design, the question changes. Did such small changes take the product outside the exclusivity promise? The factory owned the original design. That didn't give it a right to get around an exclusivity promise it had made for those markets.
The exclusivity was a right under a contract. It was separate from the design and from the molds. That led to the last problem. The brand bought through a middleman, and the exclusivity was in the middleman's contract with the factory. The brand wasn't a party to that contract. It had no direct right to ask for a copy. The middleman's side had sent an email that mentioned the arrangement. That email helped show the exclusivity existed. It couldn't tell us the actual terms.
Why I advised against spending more, for now
The brand was about to pay for a second, wider round of document review. I told it not to. The documents it already had were enough to answer the three questions. A wider review was unlikely to change the answers. Spending more would only make sense in three cases. One is if the middleman or the factory denied that the brand owned the molds. Another is if they refused to say where the molds were. The third is if the brand decided to take formal action.
The low-conflict route
The brand still wanted the factory to keep supplying. So it didn't accuse anyone. The next step was a polite written request for confirmation, based on the long relationship. The request said the brand didn't want to see prices or other terms of the middleman's contract. It only wanted the exclusivity terms: which products, which territory, how long, and whether they were still in force. A copy with the other parts blacked out would do.
This is the request, adapted for general use:
Show the clause wording
We value our long relationship with you and [factory]. We want supply to continue as normal. To keep our records complete, could you confirm in writing, for each mould in the attached list:
- that it still exists, and where it is kept;
- its present condition;
- whether it has been modified or used to make products for any other customer; and
- that it can be transferred to another factory at our request.
Please also send us a copy of the exclusivity terms for our products (scope, territory, duration). You may remove prices and any other terms that don't concern us.
At the same time, the brand collected its evidence:
- every proforma invoice and payment record for the molds;
- the emails about mold fees, starting the molds and exclusivity;
- photos comparing the original product with the new version;
- product numbers, invoices and sales pages for each version;
- the documents showing how the related company's rights passed to the company running the business now.
What happened next
The dispute did go to court. It settled through mediation during the lawsuit. The settlement confirmed that the molds belonged to the brand. The brand had paid for them.
The factory gave two reasons for keeping the molds.
- It claimed costs for material wastage and storage. There was no invoice or purchase order for them, and the brand had never been told about them. The brand paid a token amount to settle that point.
- It said a small balance the brand still owed gave it the right to keep the molds.
Both arguments would have been much weaker with a proper mold clause. The next section shows what that clause looks like. A separate article goes through the clause and what courts have done. See What Should the Mold Clause Say in a Chinese Factory Contract?
What the contract should have said
Show the clause wording
Moulds. (a) All moulds, tools and fixtures listed in Schedule [ ], and any made to replace or modify them, belong to the Buyer from the date the Buyer pays for them, whether paid separately or through the unit price. (b) The Supplier holds them for the Buyer, shall use them only to make goods for the Buyer, shall mark them "Property of [Buyer]", and shall not hold them as security or claim any right to retain them for any amount owed by the Buyer or any other person. (c) Within [15] days of the Buyer's written request, the Supplier shall make them available for collection in working condition, together with [related spare parts and drawings]. (d) On request, the Supplier shall confirm in writing where each item is kept, its condition and whether it has been modified.
Before you pay for tooling, decide three things:
- Who owns the design. Write it down either way. If the factory keeps the design, say so, and say what you get instead.
- Put the molds in the name of the company that will run the business. Then you won't need a transfer later.
- Sign the exclusivity directly with the factory. Describe the product by what it does and how it is built, as well as by model number. Then small changes won't take a product outside the promise.
Questions from overseas buyers
Can the factory keep my molds until I pay other invoices?
Chinese law lets a creditor keep property it lawfully holds when a debt is unpaid. Between businesses, the debt doesn't have to relate to the molds, as long as it arose in the ordinary course of their business (Civil Code art. 448). But if a middleman owes the factory for something else, the factory has a weak claim to keep your molds (SPC Interpretation on the Guarantee System under the Civil Code, art. 62). A contract clause saying the factory has no right to keep the molds stops most of this argument (Civil Code art. 449).
Does it matter which of my companies paid for the molds?
Yes. On paper, the molds belong to the company named as buyer on the proforma invoice. Say a related company paid. Then your current company may need a written transfer or authorisation from it before asking for the molds in its own name. So put the molds in the name of the company that will run the business.
Can the factory sell a slightly changed version of my product to other buyers?
If it used your molds to make that version, even after changing them, it used your property without permission. If it made new molds from the same design, the question is whether such small changes take the product outside the exclusivity promise. Owning the original design doesn't give the factory a right to get around an exclusivity promise it made.
I buy through a middleman. Can I see the exclusivity terms in its contract with the factory?
You have no direct right to a copy, because you aren't a party to that contract. In the matter described here, the brand sent a polite written request for the exclusivity terms only. It said a copy with prices and other terms blacked out would do.
Sources
Official texts cited in this article.
- Civil Code of the PRC (2020) npc.gov.cn
Did you pay for molds for a product you didn't design? Send a short summary and the company names. Once I've checked that I don't act for the other side, I'll ask for the invoices and anything in writing about exclusivity. If the factory is holding your molds → · Discuss your manufacturing agreement →
Part of my guide to China manufacturing agreements.
This article is based on a matter I handled. Names, products, places, dates, amounts, quantities and other identifying details have been removed or changed. It describes the advice in one matter. It doesn't predict the result in any other.
Have a China-side question?
Tell us the product and the Chinese factory. Say whether you have a draft, a signed contract or orders already running, and which documents you have. The responsible lawyer replies within one calendar day. We will tell you where you stand and what your options are.