China · Case commentary
Are Liquidated Damages Clauses Enforceable in China? Six Judgments
Overseas buyers often put a large round number into a confidentiality or exclusivity clause. The idea is that a frightening figure will scare the supplier off. Six published PRC judgments show what courts do with those figures. One clause survived at RMB 2,000,000. Another fell from RMB 6.92 million to RMB 120,000. One produced nothing at all.
What does Chinese law say about a liquidated damages clause?
A liquidated damages clause fixes in advance what one side pays if it breaks the contract. Article 585 of the Civil Code lets the parties agree such a sum, or a way to calculate the damages. If the agreed sum is far higher than the actual loss, a court may reduce it to a fair level. But it does so only if a party asks.
The Supreme People's Court interpretation on the general provisions of the contract part (Fa Shi [2023] No. 13 (in Chinese), art. 65) gives the working test. The court starts from the loss under article 584. It then weighs who the parties are and the type of deal. Also relevant are how far the contract was performed, how much each side was at fault, and the background. Fairness and good faith apply throughout. A sum more than 30% above the loss may generally be treated as excessive. A party that broke the contract in bad faith will generally get no reduction.
So the size of the number rarely decides the result. Two things usually do. Is the clause tied to something the court can calculate? And did the party attacking it bring evidence of its own? Both questions decide how I word the damages clause when I draft or review a China NNN agreement.
Six judgments, and what each one changes about your drafting
| Case | The clause and the outcome | What to draft because of it |
|---|---|---|
| Ningbo Intermediate Court (2025) Zhe 02 Min Zhong No. 7605 29 January 2026 |
A trade mark licence named the only permitted production site. Production by an unapproved third party was a fundamental breach, at RMB 2,000,000. Notarised site visits proved four unapproved locations. Full RMB 2,000,000 upheld. The licensee had already asked for approval of four other sites. So it knew the rule and broke it on purpose. | Name the permitted production site. A party that knew the rule and broke it on purpose is in bad faith under article 65. A court will then generally refuse to reduce the sum. |
| Anhui High Court (2024) Wan Min Shen No. 621 22 April 2024 |
A processing agreement barred the contractor from supplying similar parts to others. The contractor's defences failed. RMB 350,000, worked out as 30% of the buyer's lowest selling price × 160 sets sold. | Keep your cost and pricing records. If the numbers are in front of it, a court will do this sum without an expert valuation. |
| Suzhou Intermediate Court (2019) Su 05 Min Zhong No. 4940 26 November 2019 |
RMB 1,000,000 for each breach, RMB 5,000,000 for a serious breach. The buyer did not show how its rent and fit-out costs were linked to the breach. The manufacturer gave no evidence that the sum was too high. It never disclosed its own unauthorised sales. RMB 1,000,000, the per-breach figure. | Add a duty to keep records and allow an audit. The party that says the sum is too high has to prove it. A supplier that stays silent about its own sales hurts its own case. |
| Jingmen Intermediate Court (2017) E 08 Min Chu No. 47 27 August 2018 |
Damages were set at five times the value of contracts with shared customers. The clause even gave a worked example. The breach was proved. But the buyer never proved a single shared customer, so the formula could not be used. RMB 6,920,777 claimed, RMB 120,000 awarded. The drawings carried a "controlled document" stamp with no confidentiality wording. So the requirement to mark material as confidential was not met either. | A simple base you can prove beats a clever one you can't. And if the agreement says material must be marked confidential, the marking has to say so. |
| Qingdao Intermediate Court (2017) Lu 02 Min Chu No. 1428 17 June 2019 |
Five times the drawing transfer fee for leaks, and twice the value of any loss. The claimant worked back from the total yearly sales of the defendant's subsidiary. The court refused that base. There was no evidence that all its products used the technology. It used the royalties actually paid instead. RMB 4.88 million claimed, RMB 600,000 awarded. The parent company was not liable, because nobody proved the two companies' assets were mixed together. The judgment was later set aside. On appeal, the Supreme People's Court allowed the claimant to withdraw the claim after the parties settled ((2019) Zui Gao Fa Zhi Min Zhong No. 645). | Tie the loss base to products that actually used your information. Name the related companies you want bound. Don't count on a court looking through the company to its parent. |
| Shanghai Changning District Court (2008) Chang Min Er (Shang) Chu No. 112 25 June 2008 |
RMB 100,000 if the customer hired a second manufacturer. The developer found its sample at a third party and called the police. There was no contract with that party, no finished products and no delivery records. Claim dismissed. The court would not impose such a heavy liability based only on a possibility. The defendant's seal was tested by experts and found genuine. | Make the breach itself easy to prove: an unapproved site, an unauthorised subcontract, a sale to a named competitor. If the clause is built on "misuse", you must prove the misuse first. |
Five of the six are decisions of intermediate or basic-level courts. The Qingdao judgment was later set aside after a settlement. One is a provincial high court ruling that refused a retrial of the Hefei Intermediate Court's appeal judgment ((2023) Wan 01 Min Zhong No. 8812). Jingmen and Changning are first-instance judgments, and no appeal appears in the published records. Ningbo and Suzhou are appeal judgments. The first-instance cases were (2025) Zhe 0212 Min Chu No. 567 and (2018) Su 0507 Min Chu No. 952. None is a guiding case. PRC courts are not bound by earlier decisions the way a common-law court is. These cases show how courts apply articles 585 and 65 in commercial supply relationships. They do not set a rule. Results in other matters depend on their own records.
The pattern across the six
Read together, the results follow one factor. How close was the agreed figure to something the court could calculate? The RMB 2,000,000 that survived was backed by a known licence fee and a deliberate breach. The RMB 6.92 million that collapsed rested on a formula whose inputs nobody could produce.
The second factor is what the party in breach did in court. Suzhou shows this most clearly. The manufacturer never disclosed its own sales, and the court fixed the figure without that information. Staying silent did not help it. An audit clause gives you a second way to get the same numbers.
Nothing in these cases suggests that a small number is safer than a large one. Anhui produced RMB 350,000 from a clause that gave no figure at all. The buyer had its costs and its selling prices ready.
Where the clause sits in the rest of the document
The damages clause is one of eight drafting points that decide whether a China NNN (non-disclosure, non-use and non-circumvention agreement) works. The others are the definition of protected information, the language versions and the forum (the court or arbitration body that hears disputes). Then come access by subcontractors, signing and the company chop (seal), survival after the deal ends, and return or destruction. Suppose the damages clause is strong but the protected information is loosely defined. Then you have a number attached to a claim you can't prove.
Questions from overseas buyers
Is there a figure that is safe to put in the clause?
No, because the test is relative. RMB 2,000,000 was upheld in Ningbo. RMB 6.92 million became RMB 120,000 in Jingmen. The difference was whether the number was linked to a loss the court could calculate, and whether the breach was deliberate.
Does the 30% rule cap me at 130% of my loss?
Not quite. Article 65 says a sum more than 30% above the loss may generally be treated as excessive. That guides the court's assessment. It does not cap what you can recover. The test only comes into play if the party in breach asks for a reduction. A party that broke the contract in bad faith generally can't rely on it at all.
What if the supplier refuses to disclose how much it sold?
The court can still set a figure without it, as the Suzhou court did. An audit or records clause in the agreement gives you a separate way to get the same information.
Penalty or damages formula?
PRC law does not separate a penalty from a genuine estimate of loss. Article 585 covers both an agreed sum and an agreed way to calculate it. A formula tied to clear inputs is easier to defend. You can also combine the two.
Sources
Official texts cited in this article.
- Civil Code of the PRC (2020) npc.gov.cn
- Supreme People's Court Interpretation on the General Part of Contracts in the Civil Code (Fa Shi [2023] No. 13) court.gov.cn · in Chinese
Authorities: Civil Code arts. 584–585; SPC Interpretation on the General Provisions of the Contract Part of the Civil Code (Fa Shi [2023] No. 13) art. 65. Judgments cited by court, case number and date above, verifiable through China Judgments Online. English renderings of PRC titles and case names are unofficial. Verified against the primary sources on 21 September 2026.
Have a China-side question?
Tell us what you plan to share and with which Chinese company. Say whether anything has already been sent, and which documents you have. The responsible lawyer replies within one calendar day. We will tell you where you stand and what your options are.